[Icehouse] IGDC Summer 2007 Rankings

[Timothy Hunt]

taking this table (assuming it's correct), I got the same result as
dale Sheldon of

pylo > subd > zamb > geom > peng > moon > mart > trip

My working is below:

margin = 16
Zamb > Trip

Margin = 15
Moon > Trip
Zam > moon

=>  Zamb > Moon > trip

Margin = 14
Peng > Trip


Margin = 13
Geo > Trip

Margin = 12
Zamb > Mart
Peng > Mart

Margin = 11
Mart > trip
Peng > moon

=>  Zamb > mart > trip
=>  Peng > mart > trip
=>  Peng > moon > trip

Margin = 10
subd > mart
Subd > trip
Pylo > trip

=>  subd > mart > trip

Margin = 8
Pylo > Mart

=>  Pylo > mart > trip

Margin = 7
Geom > Moon

=> geom > moon > trip

margin = 5
Geom > mart
Pylo > subd

=> geom > mart > trip
=> pylo > subd > mart > trip

Margin = 4
Zamb > geom
Pylo > moon
subd > zamb

=> zamb > geom > moon > trip
=> zamb > geom > mart > trip
=> pylo > moon > trip
=> pylo > subd > zamb > geom > moon > trip
=> pylo > subd > zamb > geom > mart > trip

margin at 3
Moon > mart

=> peng > moon > mart > trip
=> pylo > subd > zamb > geom > moon > mart > trip

Margin at 2
Zam > peng )__ self-inconsistent, need to break tie
Peng > pylo )
pyl > zamb *ignored - consistent with established results
Moon > subd *ignored - inconsistent with established results

so to break tie look at how many games beaten
zamb beat 5 games
peng beat 4 games

therefore zamb > peng

=> pylo > subd > zamb > peng > moon > mart > trip

Margin at 1
geo > peng
geo > pylo *ignored - inconsistent with established results
subd > geo *ignored - consistent with established results
subd > peng *ignored - consistent with established results

=> pylo > subd > zamb > geom > peng > moon > mart > trip

Timothy

On 9/21/07, Doug Orleans <dougorleans at gmail.com> wrote:
> Here's the Marginal Vote Table:
>
>                           Geom Mart Moon Peng Pylo Subd Trip Zamb
>                   Geomancy   0    5    7    1    1   -1   13   -4
> Martian Coaster Chaturanga  -5    0   -3  -12   -8  -10   11  -12
>                  Moon Shot  -7    3    0  -11   -4    2   15  -15
>             Penguin Soccer  -1   12   11    0    2   -1   14   -2
>                      Pylon  -1    8    4   -2    0    5   10    2
>                Subdivision   1   10   -2    1   -5    0   10    4
>                  Trip Away -13  -11  -15  -14  -10  -10    0  -16
>               Zamboni Wars   4   12   15    2   -2   -4   16    0
>
> See Zarf's explanation for details about what the table means and how
> to get from there to the final ranking.
> http://icehousegames.com/contest/rp-table-desc.html
>
> --dougorleans at gmail.com
> _______________________________________________
> Icehouse mailing list
> Icehouse at lists.looneylabs.com
> http://lists.looneylabs.com/mailman/listinfo/icehouse
>